Hate speeches must be stopped - Instablogs
Hate speeches must be stopped
Abdullah Khan , Hyderabad: Apr 2 2009
Made Popular Apr 2 2009
India :

Hate speeches must be stopped

Hate politics in our country surfaces mainly during election time. In a country which lives on razor-edge social relations, inflammatory speeches are just the right dose for stoking communal passions. If there are elections, the degree of such hate speeches increases manifold. The Shiv Sena was the trend-setter in Maharashtra and many saffron outfits too have contributed to this divisive politics. It was LK Advani’s rath yatra which triggered communal politics and the country did not recover from that phase yet. The BJP skillfully raised the Ram temple issue whenever it was bereft of any agenda on its list.

After that, the politics of hate has been the chief instrument of expansion for the Hindutva forces. Varun Gandhi, BJP’s latest Hindutva posterboy is also using the same tool of hate. This is not the first time that this bogey of hate is being directed towards the Muslim community. Varun’s peer in the saffron brigade have been saying the same thing for years.The question that arises is, what role does law play, when politics divides people in different groups on religious basis or regional basis?

The Indian Penal Code has a number of provisions penalising spiteful speeches. Sections 153A and B as also Sections 295A and 505 criminalise writings and speeches made against a religious community or against their religion.

The nearest is Section 295(A) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), which punishes with fine and imprisonment up to 3 years speech, writings, or signs which ‘‘with deliberate and malicious intention’’ insult the religion or the religious beliefs of any class of citizens. Section 153(a) of the Indian Penal Code states that anyone whose words, “whether spoken or written,” promote “disharmony” or “feelings of enmity” between different communities may face up to three years in prison. A related provision is Section 153B which proscribes imputations that any class of persons cannot be loyal citizens because they are members of a religious group or community.But the question arises here is: How effective are these laws?

We need stringent laws which can ensure that the likes of Varun Gandhi, Togadia, Bal Thackrey, Raj Thackrey, Sadhvi Ritambha etc. do not get away despite their anti-national politics and utterances. It must debar him from election process forever. The rule of law should prevail to give confidence oppressed citizens of the nation.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Manishkumar
Kottayam, India
Whatever Varun has told is unfortunate, but whatever happened after that is more unfortunate.

I am unable to understand our politics and their double standard. If Muslim league or SIMI would have not been taken as secular speech. But comments of Varun Gandhi, candidate of BJP, is taken as communal.

In democracy everyone has right to say. It means everyone even majorities also. We should not debate on this matter and should leave this topic for politicians, so they can earn some votes on that.
1 Stars
Abdullah Khan
Hyderabad, India
I am not saying that only Varun Gandhi is communal and he is only using the tool of hate. Many Muslim outfits too have contributed to this divisive
politics stoking passions between the two communities for political
benefits.
1 Stars
Puneet
Noida, India
now a days these politicians are using religions for there votes. Ok if anythg wrong happens between any religion n hindu will he really come to save us. all these politicians knows to play with sentiments of Indian whether its varun gandhi, lallo prasad yadav, amar singh, raj thacarey or anyone else. they are doing all these for vote bank. during festivals hindu muslims are bhai bhai, they help each other but when any politicians says anything in favour of 1 religion then that bhaichar turns into enimity. Why we Indians forget that now we are educated people? why we still dont use our brain? why we get influenced by thse dirty mind? why we forget when we are born we are 1st human being after that we come 2 know we belong to this language/caste/religion,etc.
1 Stars
Abdullah Khan
Hyderabad, India
This is very disturbing that we don’t use our brains. The biggest challenge we face today is to propogate the inclusive ideas at social, political and cultural level.
1 Stars
Sachin Kumar
shimla, India
Only law will not be sufficient to deal with such people. Through law we can only penalize the culprits spreading the hatred among the communities.We have to cure the causes of disease. We have to isolate the people and parties spreading the communal thoughts.
1 Stars
Abdullah Khan
Hyderabad, India
Hate speeches are the outcome of politics of divisiveness. You are absolutely right that we We have to isolate the people and parties spreading the communal thoughts.
1 Stars
Sumit
Agra, India
Hate speeches have become common in politics. Line dividing between aggressive talking and hate speech is thin. But going by comparison with what many politicians have been uttering in hatred against religions and castes, Varun should only be included in the 'aggressive" category and not in hate propaganda.
1 Stars
Abdullah Khan
Hyderabad, India
Mr Sumit
Varun Gandhi was pouring vitriol against particular community. He presented the usual prejudices and biases in a very hateful manner. So Varun should not be only be included in the ’aggressive” category.
1 Stars
Usha
Chennai, India
Hate speeches are only going to make situation volatile. Political parties should desist from these. Our politicians should show maturity and not field candidates who are hell bent upon igniting the country. It is immaterial whether the candidate belongs to the minority or the majority community.
2 Stars
Sachin Kumar
shimla, India
How can the political parties formed on the basis of hate against the other communities desist from hate speeches? They can’t give up their basic thought .
1 Stars
Abdullah Khan
Hyderabad, India
Undoubtedly hate speeches are only going to make situation volatile.But Political nincompoop will never desist from these.Because politics of hate has been the chief instrument of expansion for many political parties
2 Stars
Amit Vashist
chandigarh, India
My dear friend it is very natural that number of people like you will start teaching classes on Hate speaches as you are a Muslim and living in a nation where being Muslim means minority and being member of minority class you are free to speak any thing . In parliament during Amar nath temple dispute , Abdula and other Muslim leaders said , they are fighting for their land Hindues are alians for that land also Mufti and party coated the same but at that time no nationalist raised the voice . you are free to speak not because you are Muslim but because Hindues ARE in majority. In Kashmir Muslims have looted lands and housesof Hindues but no body is coming for their assistence. Three young boys were killed in Meeruth U P in monthMay08, no humanist came forward to supprt the desiesded families. Yes all Hindu leaders require Punishment because they are not loyel even to their voters and followers.
2 Stars
Hiten
Ranchi, India
@Amit

yes you are right! I've seen the parliament session when there was an Amarnath temple dispute and I have also read about the three Hindu boys killed Meeruth...but does that mean we should start doing the same. Does that mean we should push nation on the 1947 lines to see nation partitioned yet again. we can't afford that.

these incidents are sad and the muslims are always the making hue and cry when something wrong happens to side. On the other I wonder if they are in minority even as of now. Secondly, this is all happening bcoz of our stinking politicians who are ignoring everything for some short term benefits. So amit this is the right time to kick such politicians out of our parliament even though it is choosing the least corrupt among the corrupts.
1 Stars
Abdullah Khan
Hyderabad, India
There Are Some Black Sheeps in every religion. I am criticizing all the communal persons belonging from a Minority community or majority community. I am not supporting any one who is promoting hatred.
But I think there is along list of leaders belonging from a hindutva communal brigade. Have u forgotten the name of Narendra Modi or Praveen Togadia. Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray and his estranged nephew Maharashtra Navnirman Sena leader Raj Thackeray made their political careers by giving controversial speeches or writing fiery edits.Hindu leaders Ashok Singhal, Uma Bharati and Sadhvi Ritambara have also been booked for controversial speeches,
1 Stars
Chintan
Ambala, India
I wonder if BJP can ever raise voice against the discrimination against Muslims.It's OK that BJP fought the Amar Nath land acquisition issue but have ever BJP talked about plight of Muslims in the country. You are talking about three boys. Thousands of victims of post Godhra riots are getting justice after seven years.
1 Stars
Abdullah Khan
Hyderabad, India
You are right Mr Chintan
After having propagated hatred for last few decades, thousands of persons have been killed, in hundreds of riots in India. Neither the judiciary nor the administration has been able to convict or punish the men responsible. The rule of law should prevail to give confidence to the oppressed victims of our nation.
1 Stars
Sachin Kumar
shimla, India
The rule of law should prevail but its not happening in India. Victims of post Godhra riots are getting justice after seven years. Justice delayed is justice denied.
1 Stars
Abdullah Khan
Hyderabad, India
Everything is topsy-turvy today.
Add your Comment